Let's face it, there's lots of natural peanut butter's out there, but before Emily, we were a Skippy household. My husband and I are both big fans of PB sandwiches (although he prefers PB&J), and our favorite is now Skippy's Natural Peanut Butter which is soy free.
http://www.peanutbutter.com/natural.asp
It's got the same great Skippy taste (it's even won a tasting award), but it does get a little bit oily (much less than I would have expected). Of course this isn't recommended for infants, but I highly recommend it to older kids and adults who are allergic to soy.
Our household rating: 9/10 (only because of the oil)
